*NOTE* - 165 lbs was a weird weight for the '25-'26 season. For one there were a ton of backups/reserves with wins over NCAA D3 qualifiers! Like way more than you would expect. Secondly & even more concerning, were the # of NCAA D3 qualifiers with losses to guys that didn't even place in their Regional. That really threw me off. I guess it goes to show how much of a convoluted mess the whole qualifying system is in NCAA Division III. I think you'll get a better glimpse of what I'm saying as you read along.
 |
#11 Jon Harvey UW-Eau Claire 165 |
Entering Regional 7 with a 17-4 record, Jon Harvey won two matches & then lost three extremely close matches in a row to finish in 6th place. On the year had two victories over Regional 7 3rd place finisher Dylan Cariveau by scores of 10-6 & 7-3. Also had a 7-4 decision over Regional 4 runner-up Cade Parent.
 |
#15 Ethan Composto Gettysburg 165 |
Ethan Composto getting beat out of Regional III really threw me for a loop. I thought the bullet would be lead poisoning all the way up until the finals, where he would meet the bulletproof vest that is Keegan DeMarest. I don't know what went wrong for the Petrofes runner-up. On the season he nearly majored the runner-up Justice Hockenberry-Folk & he defeated 3rd place finisher Nicky Bell 9-5. The light at the end of the tunnel here is, Composto has another season to go.
 |
#16 Kale Roth Dubuque 165 |
I had the privilege of interviewing this class act a few months ago at a quadrangular. Simply put, Kale Roth was a victim of an incredibly stacked weight class in Regional 6. 24-5 on the year, he finished 5th at the Regional & he was the Concordia (Wis) runner-up. He too has one more season of collegiate eligibility left.
 |
#19 Landon Kearns USCGA 165 |
My heart goes out to Landon Kearns. 4th a year ago in Regional 1, this year he finishes 5th. When he goes into his senior season of '26-'27, he'll easily make the list for best yet to qualify. Hell, he'll probably make the best for best yet to All-American. Trust me, the guy has proven himself. 25-6 on the season. Let me tell you about some of his wins.
4-3 tiebreaker over Regional 1 champion Jack Richardson
4-2 over Regional 1 runner-up Jashon Holmes
8-5 over Regional 2 3rd placer Tyler Roe
21-7 major over Regional 3 3rd placer Nicky Bell
 |
U.R. Mark Troni Washington & Lee |
80 career wins, a four time Old-Dominion Athletic Conference finalist & a four-time Regional 4 place-winner. I'm sure Mark Troni wanted to add another NCAA D3 qualification to his resume, but nonetheless, I'd say the General had himself a pretty fine career. He was 7th-5th-3rd-4th in his Regional appearances. Had a 13-3 major decision over Justice Hockenberry-Folk.
 |
U.R. Joey Jens Millikin 165 |
I thought before his career was all said & done that Joey Jens would have called himself an NCAA D3 qualifier at least once. Didn't happen, but he did come awful close twice. 5th last year & 4th this year in Regional 5. A Collegiate Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin champion, he finished out just a handful of wins shy of 100. I must add how much the Jens brothers remind me of the Uker brothers from years back, Mike & Ben. Style, the way they carry themselves off the mat. They even sorta look like them.
 |
U.R. Aiden Brosinski Wartburg 165 |
I don't know if Aiden Brosinski has more eligibility left or not. I'd like to think that he does. 4th the past two Regional 6's in a row, the Knight finished off '25-'26 with a 19-7 record. A champion at the Concordia (WIS) open.
 |
U.R. Aiden Stecker Mount Union 165 |
I believe Mount Union could very well be looking at their next All-American in Aiden Stecker. The freshman won 21 matches this season, including sticking Regional 4 3rd place finisher Ben Hegler at the 2:18 mark. Finishing 5th at Regional 5, he was 8th at Pete Willson.
 |
U.R. Mike Roberts Westminster 165
|
"Go for broke" Mike Roberts was a guy that went for it every time he stepped onto the mat. 4th-6th-8th-6th at Regional 6, he never did make the NCAA D3 championships, but he did have a great career. An exciting wrestler that went for it every time he stepped on the mat, regardless of who he was wrestling. He was fearless & a 3:29 fall over Tanner Gerber, who will contend for the 2026 D3 title in a couple of weeks is proof enough of that. Matter of fact, Roberts racked up 19 falls this year alone!
 |
U.R. Mekhi Cave North Central 165 |
Freshmen can sometimes take a while to work out the kinks in their first year of collegiate wrestling & I think that's the case with Mekhi Cave. At North Central he is under phenomenal guidance & leadership, and I think all mistakes will be fixed, as strengths will be maximized. In other words, I think in the years coming, Mekhi Cave will be very good. Beat out of Regional 5 this year, Cave showed promise various times throughout '25-'26. A 3-2 win over Regional 6 champion Boe Koedam, & a 6-5 win over Regional 2 runner-up Carter Davis.
 |
U.R. Taggart Kazmierczak Wheaton 165 |
Beat out of Regional 5 & a record just above .500 some might roll their eyes at me for including Taggart Kazmierczak on this list. I'll tell you why included him. 8-5 & 10-6 wins over Brayden Peet. A 15-6 major over Ben Hegler. 4th at Pete Willson. This guy is obviously a hot & cold wrestler. Has one more season of eligibility left.
Two others that some might include on the list are freshmen Viviano Gutierrez of USMMA & Austin Dipzinski of Heidelberg. Both had wins over 2026 NCAA D3 qualifiers.
Now for 174...
I said we weren't going to count backups/reserves in our evaluation, and we won't be, but I have to note this. Eddie Simes, Noah Leisgang's backup at UW-La Crosse is they best backup in all of NCAA D3 wrestling. I'm talking good enough to be an NCAA D3 champion next year.
 |
#12 Carson Trotzer UW-Stevens Point 174 |
6th-4th-4th at Regional 7, Carson Trotzer now enters the world of best yet to qualify for NCAA D3 championships. 23-7 on the year, 5th at the Concordia (Wis) Open, 3rd at the WIAC & a Pete Willson champ. Wins over Jack Hoffman (3rd R4) & Jermaine Butler (2nd R5). He'll be a senior in '26-'27.
 |
#13 Preston Carlisle UW-Eau Claire 174 |
Unfortunately there will not be another shot for Preston Carlisle. The Blugold closes out his senior campaign as one of the best in NCAA D3 wrestling to not make the 2026 national tournament. 5th the past two Regional 7's, as well as 5th at Pete Willson, here are the notable wins he had this season.
2:22 fall over Zach Needles 3rd at Regional 3
10-5 over Xavier Preston who is now a three-time NCAA D3 qualifier
8-2 over Regional 5 runner-up Jermaine Butler
10-5 over Nick Alexander 3rd at Regional 7
I'd say despite having never made the D3 championships, that's still a very impressive list of wins!
 |
U.R. Patrick Wisniewski Johnson & Wales 174 |
I don't know the specifics of the situation. Teammate & Rider transfer Shane Reitsma had the #20 ranking & wrestled a ot more this season. Wisniewski, 8th in the D3 nation last season, finished off his career with a record of 6-6. Not sure if it was a straight up Reitsma was beating Wisniewski out for the spot, or if injuries were involved. What I do know is that Wisniewski placed 5th at Regional 1 & it should be noted that while at Regional 1, he handed Jake DeGuire a 7-3 loss. It is thus far DeGuire's only loss on the season.
 |
U.R. Ian Flanagan Stevens Tech 174 |
A 20+ match winner this season, Ian Flanagan finished one match shy of earning NCAA D3 qualification. Among his wins, a 16-10 decision over Jack Hoffman who was 3rd at Regional 4.
 |
U.R. Tony Cerulli Ursinus 174 |
90 career wins, 35 of them this season & back-to-back 4th place finishes at Regional 3. Yeah, a guy like Tony Cerulli belongs on a list like this. Runner-up finishes at both the Racich Rumble & the New Standard Invite, Cerulli is one I'm sure Coach Jamison is going to miss having around next season.
 |
U.R. Aiden Ashburn John Carroll 174 |
An NCAA D3 R12'er back in 2024, things didn't quite end the way they should have for Aiden Ashburn of John Carroll. He finished out his collegiate wrestling career with 22 wins this season, one of which was a 1:42 fall over Jack Hoffman who was 3rd at Regional 4. Ashburn himself was 5th at Regional 5.
 |
U.R. Christian Gilbert Carthage 174 |
Heart goes out to Christian Gilbert. Hate to see a guys' career end the way his did, but this is the sport of wrestling and that is the way it goes sometimes. Gilbert was beaten out of Regional 7, which by having both #12 Carson Trotzer & #13 Preston Carlisle both not Q out of, you know how tough of a qualifier it was! Despite not placing at R7, Gilbert still had a very notable final year of wrestling. 29 wins on the season & not just any wins. We're talking....
8-5 sv. over Regional 5 champ Jaylen Young
17-11 over Regional 5 runner-up Jermaine Butler
8-5 over Regional 5 3rd place finisher Jake Luce
There are other names for 174, but that is JT1Wrestle's list.
Now for 184...
*
NOTE* - Usually the wild, crazy, chaos of collegiate wrestling is saved for the lower weights. It's usually 125 & 133, where things can become a disarray of madness. However, things up here at 184 are seeking serious psychiatric evaluation. To start things off, 7 of the top 20 wrestlers at 184 are staying home. That's well of 1/4 of the wrestlers that earned a top 20 ranking this season....and they are NOT going to the NCAA D3 championships. The other point I have to make is that of those that are going, many of them didn't wrestle at 184 all season. We had many move down from 197 towards the end of the year, some at the very tail end of it. A few others that wrestled a lot of matches at 174. As I explained in evaluating other weights, I'm sticking to the 184 lbs weight class, when I talk the 184 lbs weight class.
This list is long...real long, but every name I have on here, belongs on here, and I'll more than provide justification as to why.
 |
#6 Myles Leonard Springfield 184 |
The four-time NWCA Academic All-American won 100 matches during his NCAA D3 wrestling career. He only lost twice this season & unfortunately that put him at the dreaded 4th place finish in Regional 1. Among his wins on the season, an 8-1 decision over Regional 1 runner-up Desi McLaughlin.
 |
#10 Hayden McLellan Alvernia 184 |
Things may not have ended the way Hayden McLellan wanted them to this season, but he should be headed into '26-'27 with a lot of hope & confidence. The sophomore collected 41 wins this year & a Petrofes championship. A 5-2 decision over Regional 3 runner-up Justin Mayes, McLellan has Regional 3 finishes of 8th & 5th thus far.
 |
#11 Abdoul Akala Albright 184 |
The freshman learned how cruel & unforgiving the world of collegiate wrestling can be sometimes, when he came up short of a top 8 finish at Regional 3. Nonetheless, with three seasons left in his career, the future looks bright for Abdoul Akala. 26-5 on the year, he showed up what he can do by knocking off Regional 2 champ Sean Malenfant 7-6.
 |
#14 Zak McPhee UW-Eau Claire |
The sophomore ended out his '25-'26 with a 20-8 record which included a WIAC title & a 4th place showing at the Pete Willson Invitational. Among his wins he stuck Regional 7 champion Easton Hull on two occasions! 6:37 & 6:19. Also defeated Robert Flege! McPhee was 5th at regional 7.
 |
#15 Austin Brass Messiah 184 |
An NCAA D3 R12'er in 2025, Austin Brass ends his collegiate career just a hair shy of earning a second NCAA D3 qualification & just a hair shy of 100 career wins.
 |
#16 Vitali Daniels Washington & Jefferson 184 |
The Edinboro transfer had a great first year of NCAA D3 wrestling, technically still only a freshman. 5th at Regional 4, he was 25-4 on the year with 8-5 victories over qualifiers Eli Crum & Jack Ryan.
 |
#18 Noah McIlroy Stevens Tech 184 |
I know for a fact that Coach Bonaventura is excited for what his freshman has in store as a sophomore, junior & senior. 5th at Regional 2 this season, he came up a bit short of being an NCAA D3 qualifier, but in three years from today, I wouldn't be at all surprised if JT1wrestle wasn't writing about a three-time qualifier. 22-6 on the year, we're talking nearly majoring Regional 5 champ Jackson Davis 12-5. Then another decisive victory, 9-3 over Regional 7 champ Easton Hull!
 |
U.R. Austin Wilkins Cornell (IA) 184 |
Austin Wilkins is testimony to just how talented & good you have to be to even make a lineup in NCAA Division III wrestling. A backup for the majority of his career, Wilkins made the most of his final season of collegiate wrestling. 20 wins on the season, this included a 4-3 win over Regional 7 champ Easton Hull. 6th at Pete Willson, he was 4th at Regional 6.
 |
U.R. Xavier Pommells Ithaca 184 |
2nd at Regional 2 & 8th in the D3 nation a year ago, Xavier Pommells came up short of another Q this season finishing 4th at Regional 2. 20 wins on the season, he has one more year left to go.
 |
U.R. Blaine Chrisman Mount Union 184 |
22-7 on the year, freshman Blaine Chrisman gave up plenty of reason to be excited about his future in NCAA Division III wrestling. 4th at Regional 4, the Raider showed us he's a pinner. 4:23 & 2:15 falls over D3 qualifier Khalil Mitchell. A 6:48 fall over qualifier Matt Gummere. Not to mention a 6-1 decision over Regional 4 runner-up Remmington Bauer.
 |
U.R. Ajay Lock Ohio Northern 184 |
Ajay Locke, another example of how in one's career there is so much more to it than whether you ever made the national tournament or not. 5th at Pete Willson, Locke had a 4-2 decision over Regional 4 champ Hunter Moore & a 4-2 win over Matt Gummere who was 3rd at Regional 5.
 |
U.R. Zach Huckaby Wabash 184 |
33 wins on the season for the sophomore who finished one match shy of NCAA D3 qualification at Regional 5. had a 4-2 win over Regional 4 runner-up Remmington Bauer & a 4-2 win over Matt Gummere.
I know I said I wouldn't speak much to this, but I gotta put in a word for Mike Teheny here too. He wrestled at 184 all season long & then moved up to 197 for the Regionals. With Teheny a freshman this year & Huckaby a sophomore, I don't know what Wabash will do next season. Here's some of what Teheny looked like at 184 this year...
19-13 over Regional 1 runner-up Desi McLaughlin
3:52 fall over Matt Gummere 3rd at Regional 5
1:22 fall over Regional 4 runner-up Remmington Bauer
 |
U.R. Zach Miller Johnson & Wales 184 |
25 wins on the season, Zach Miller is another super tough sophomore who came up a bit short of NCAA D3 qualification this year. 5th at Regional 1, he dismantled Regional 1 runner-up Desi McLaughlin earlier this season 22-4 technical fall.
 |
U.R. R.J. Samuels Cornell (IA) 184 |
R.J. Samuels was all over the place this season. Ups and down. If you don't like roller coasters, he may not be the wrestler for you to follow. Nevertheless, when he was on, he was on. Defeated Regional 7 champ Easton Hull 5-4 & had a win over Matt Gummere 8-2.
 |
U.R. Wills Bronson John Carroll 184 |
Wills Bronson... I debated whether to add him or leave him off this list for a long time. To be fair and objective, I do not think he had as good of a junior season as he had a sophomore season. And that's not just because he ended last year with a 2nd place finish at Regional 5 & this year he was 5th. There are other factors as well. Nonetheless, potentially speaking, he's capable of doing many great things in his final season next year. I do believe he'll make it back to the D3 championships in 2027.